Letters to the Editor

 Originally printed in the NOVEMBER-DECEMBER 2008 issue of Quest magazine. 
Citation:  "Letters to the Editor." Quest  96.6 (NOVEMBER-DECEMBER 2008):.

Richard,
 
I am writing to applaud your suggestions for the future direction of The Quest. I completely agree. It strikes me that from issue to issue articles appear that are largely a permutation of words and ideas from articles in previous issues. 
 
I am one of those readers who "adhere to the Society's core principles, including the idea that there is a universal 'secret doctrine' that has been expressed over the millennia in countless and often apparently contradictory forms." I welcome "wide and disparate viewpoints," and "literate, stimulating, and spiritually enlivening writing." 
 
We all seek to evolve spiritually, become more compassionate, practice mindfulness, etc., but to me the magazine is overbalanced in that area. I wonder if Theosophists consider that their founder's "Secret Doctrine" is more about the inner mechanisms of the universe than about "working on ourselves," or "being a better person," even though those goals are of great importance. 
 
In spite of the validity of the perennial philosophy, there is also something to be said for adapting our inner lives to keep in sync with the ever more rapidly shifting outer reality we now live in. 
 
I sometimes feel like The Quest is a magazine from the past that has time-traveled into the present. 
I'm encouraged that you are now the editor.
 
—Monte Zerger
Alamosa, Colorado

 

Dear Mr. Smoley, 
 
     I'm very happy to see you as executive editor of The Quest! Gnosis used to be the only spiritual magazine that I found at the time which I felt sufficiently worthwhile to subscribe to. It was a big loss when it folded. Even now the number of spiritual magazines I do get is small: apart from The Quest, The Mountain Path (Advaita), Venture Inward, Atlantis Rising, and Nexus are the only ones I subscribe to that have some spiritual content, although the latter two of course are much broader.
 
     I think the big challenge for you is that TS has been in the doldrums for a long time. The value of the TS, of course, is that it is not a religion. I am firmly convinced that religion is the bane of spirituality, and the TS makes sure not to preach dogma, nor does it have a hierarchy that needs to fatten themselves or dominate others. But it cannot do much if it comes across as geriatric. 
 
     So I think something has to be done to make it clear that new folks and new ideas are on the rise. Spirituality is of great value to all, not just old folks. Indeed you can see this if you go to most New Age bookshops—I do not feel that they cater primarily to the elderly. So, in principle, TS should be able to capture the same broader demographic. 
 
     One very small suggestion I would have is to get David Icke to write something. His book Infinite Love Is the Only Truth, Everything Else Is Illusion constitutes the most remarkably panoramic view of spirituality that I've encountered in any book. He is primarily known as a lecturer on Illuminati/conspiracy/ET topics, but he has achieved an amazing depth of spiritual knowledge and this particular book (of his many) puts it across forcefully.
 
—Vytenis Babrauskas, Ph.D.
Issaquah, Washington

 

Dear Betty Bland,
 
Why are you still using glossy paper for The Quest when other options are more environmentally responsible?
     Thanks to you and your team for holding the light of Theosophy in our challenging world!
 
—Michael Burtt
Emigrant, Montana
 
Editor's note: Good question, and one that we get from time to time. The quick answer is that we use glossy paper for its esthetic value. We don't use recycled paper for the very simple and unfortunately very crucial reason that it is still more expensive than nonrecycled. Like much of the nation, we are facing tight strictures on our budget. Our paper stock is, we believe, the best choice available for both appearance and affordability.

 

John Algeo, in his article on Colonel Olcott (Sept.-Oct. 2008), makes the following statement: "Today, the 'theory' of evolution is accepted fact, and the means by which physical evolution happens are fairly well known. Except for some dogmatic religious fundamentalists no one doubts [its] reality."
 
     Not true. Over five hundred scientists have signed on to this statement "We are skeptical of claims for the ability of random mutation and natural selection to account for the complexity of life. Careful examination of the evidence for Darwinian theory should be encouraged."
 
     The changes needed to account for the development of even the simplest life forms require multiple random events to occur simultaneously. When the mathematics of probability are applied to this event, the time period required easily exceeds the age of the universe.
 
     Another problem for the Darwinists is the existence of the irreducible complexity of certain biological systems. Michael Behe, a professor of biochemistry at Lehigh University, spells this out in his book Darwin's Black Box. There are many more anomalies in Darwin's paradigm, but they are not taught or discussed in our schools for fear of challenging the scientism of the day. Thomas Huxley stated over a century ago: "Even if Darwinism is clearly false above the microevolutionary level, it is nevertheless the only scientific theory available, and that is more important than the question of truth or falsity."
 
     Lastly, I would suggest that John get a copy of Intelligence Came First (1975) by E. Lester Smith, a Theosophist and Fellow of the Royal Society who raised many of the same objections to Darwinian evolution that are now getting some attention.
 
—Herbert Lubitz
Wilmington, Delaware
 
Editor's note: The statement mentioned above is entitled "A Scientific Dissent from Darwinism," promulgated in 2001 by the Discovery Institute, a conservative think tank based in Washington, D.C. To view the list of signers, visit http://www.dissentfromdarwin.org .

 

     I enjoyed Richard Smoley's article, "The Future of Esoteric Christianity," in the July-Aug. issue. I thought that esotericism was an occult idea. The article made it clear that as a Catholic Christian, I was an "esoteric" without realizing it, as I was always oriented toward the mystery of things while keeping a distance from what was going on in the institutional side.
 
     The article says that "the human race is ready for something different." Over thirty years ago I was introduced to an idea that was indeed profound. Thomas Berry [author of The Dream of the Earth and other works] was the man with that vision. He has proposed to take Christianity out of the age of Aquinas and into a vision of cosmogenesis—a self-regulating, emergent universe that has had a psychic dimension from the beginning. He has called for a theology of reconciliation between humans and the earth and for a worldview that is scientific in its data and mystic in its form.
 
—Frank Sutherland
Hanna, Alberta, Canada

 

Dear Mr. Smoley,
 
Shame on you. Your otherwise excellent article on "The Future of Esoteric Christianity" was remiss in failing to mention Unity as one "denomination" that is oriented toward the esoteric perspective. Charles and Myrtle Fillmore were very familiar with Blavatsky's works, and many Theosophical tenets resonate throughout Unity philosophy. I cannot believe that you are unfamiliar with Unity, but if you are not, I would suggest you become so. One good book is The Unity Movement: Its Evolution and Spiritual Teachings by Neal Vahle.
 
     I'm not trying to be sarcastic. I really can't believe that you made no mention of Unity in your article.
 
—Jeff Cosby
Greenville, Illinois

 

The Quest welcomes letters to the editor. We reserve the right to edit letters for clarity, content, and length.


The Vitality of Living Truth

By Joy Mills

Originally printed in the NOVEMBER-DECEMBER 2008 issue of Quest magazine. 
Citation: Mills, Joy. "The Vitality of Living Truth." Quest  96.6 (NOVEMBER-DECEMBER 2008):207-210, 225.

Theosophical Society - Joy Mills was an educator who served as President of the Theosophical Society in America from 1965–1974, and then as international Vice President for the Theosophical Society based in Adyar

PERHAPS SOME OF YOU HAVE BEEN AS ENCHANTED as I have been by Richard Bach's work Curious Lives, in which he has recounted "Adventures from the Ferret Chronicles." Bach is probably best known as the author of Jonathan Livingston Seagull, but his "Ferret Chronicles" make for a most delightful read. In the foreword to Curious Lives, Bach informs us that for half a century he has been asking such questions as, "Is the world in our mind . . . and not outside? What if all we see about us are reflections of what we think is so? What's reflected when we decide to change our thought?" He goes on to say how bored he has become with "drama about evil, films about war and malice and crime," so that if he had "to watch one more prison scene, one more aggression, one more gigantic spectacular stupendous explosion on-screen," he would "walk out and rebuild the universe."
 
Bach then continues with his questions: "What if . . . a culture grew up without evil, without crime or war? What would it do with all the energies that we squander on our destructions? How would it feel to live in a world where we choose our highest right and not our darkest wrong, where we lift each other instead of always and ever putting each other down?"
 
Good questions, those, particularly because they set me to asking some of my own: What would the world be like if every individual who believed in the Theosophical ideal of universal brotherhood really lived in accordance with that principle? More to the point, what would happen if I not only acknowledged but actually lived the stupendous, mind-shattering, heart-inspiring, fundamental truth that there is only One Life? What if, joined by others who are equally bored by the endless diet of scandal, political corruption, corporate greed, and road rage, I set out to rebuild the world?
 
In concluding The Key to Theosophy, HPB responds to questions concerning the future of Theosophy and of the Theosophical Society. In the first instance, she states unequivocally that Theosophy "will ever exist throughout the infinitudes of the Future," because it "is synonymous with Everlasting Truth." In regard to the future of the Society, however, her response is cast in problematic terms: "Its future will depend almost entirely upon the degree of selflessness, earnestness, devotion, and last, but not least, on the amount of knowledge and wisdom possessed by those members, on whom it will fall to carry on the work."
 
When asked why knowledge should be such a vital factor, HPB states that it is not a matter of "technical knowledge of the esoteric doctrine," but rather of the kind of knowledge that possesses "that vitality which living truth alone can impart." All too frequently, knowledge has been equated with information, with what we sometimes call "hard facts," but it is quite obvious that HPB had something else in mind when she used that word. So let us pursue a little further what she may have meant by knowledge in this context, even equating it with "living truth" and therefore with Theosophy itself.
 
There is a unique part of the Mahatma Letters, published as an appendix to the volume The Letters of H. P. Blavatsky to A. P. Sinnett, and more recently to the chronological edition of The Mahatma Letters to A. P. Sinnett under the title "Cosmological Notes." The document begins with the question "What are the different kinds of knowledge?", to which the response is given, "The real and the unreal," with the added comment that "real knowledge deals with eternal verities and primal causes."
 
"Real knowledge," "eternal verities," "living truth": these are but a few of the terms that, when examined closely, may describe a state of knowing that transforms us completely. Consider, for example, the statement by one of the Mahatmas in a letter to Sinnett: "Real Knowledge . . . is not a mental but a spiritual state, implying full union between the Knower and the Known" (Letter 69, chronological edition). And consider also a statement in the "Cosmological Notes" which tells us that Real Knowledge "becomes Fohat . . . in its activity," indicating the dynamic, vital, living quality of true knowing. Fohat, which HPB called "an occult Tibetan term" for that primordial cosmic energy that brings about a manifested system, is the animating principle linking Universal Mind or consciousness with the vehicles in which that consciousness becomes individualized. Furthermore, HPB equates Fohat with eros, which is simply to say that real knowledge is the energy or dynamic of love. Although more could be said about Fohat, our concern at present is not with the technicalities of cosmic processes. While recognizing that true knowledge is an energy that moves, sustains, and transforms, our immediate focus is on exploring the essential knowing, the "living truth," that so vitalizes us that we do indeed create a new world.
 
We may read the phrase "the living truth" in two ways: first, as the necessity for each of us to live the truth, our own truth, the truth as we know it when we see things as they are, not as we might wish them to be or as the mind conceives them; and, second, as the essential fact that truth by its very nature is living, dynamic, vibrant, and capable of transforming us. As the contemporary cosmologist Brian Swimme has said, "Deep truths challenge us profoundly. To understand them demands a change in ourselves along with a creative leap of the imagination." The late president of the Theosophical Society, N. Sri Ram, put the matter this way: "The Truth which we seek must be the Truth of direct experience, in which the distinction between subject and object has ceased to exist." He added that "Truth is a becoming, but each must find it by the realization of it within himself. And he can realize it only as he seeks to embody it in his life, so that all one is and does becomes more and more beautiful each day."
 
To seek Truth, to know the wholeness of Truth as actual experience: that is the journey on which we are really engaged. The Theosophical author J. J. van der Leeuw beautifully and powerfully expressed the nature of this seeking in his book The Conquest of Illusion: "Unless we ask with our whole being, heart and soul and mind, unless we can hardly eat or drink or sleep unless we know, unless life is no longer worth living without the experience of living truth, we shall not gain it. We must desire truth more than life itself if we are to be worthy of experiencing it."
 
Even if we consider that truth as an absolute is beyond conception, we may yet discover that as a reality truth is not beyond experience. It is essentially inherent in experience and in the "experiencer" when the distinction between the two has ceased to exist. It is the discovery of that reality which seats us, as it were, in the livingness of truth, so that we are no longer content with concepts that have in no way changed us or transformed us. Concepts are simply constructs of the mind, satisfying our hunger for logic and reason. But the experience of truth calls us to be other than we are; it transforms us from within so that we can never be the same again. Truth answers to a deeper hunger within us, beyond the mind and yet not mindless, rooted in the consciousness of the One, the hunger to know, to experience the Real.
 
There is a vast difference between knowing something intellectually and knowing it as a lived experience. For the Theosophist, I would suggest, the gap between intellectual knowledge and the living truth is fatal, for the former may leave us essentially unmoved in possession of concepts that, while perhaps beautiful in themselves, have never touched us. As a result, our lives continue in the programmed patterns of the past, which we call our karma, and we walk the world almost as the "living dead." The other, the living truth, known and experienced in the depths of our being, continually acts within us to give us renewed vitality, energy, and strength to meet whatever occurs on our journey. By intellectual knowledge, we may know about many things and be able to discourse about numerous ideas. By the experience of truth itself, we know the one thing that really matters and we are constantly renewed from within.
 
Out of this genuine experience there arises the question: What action, what movement within me, is necessary to translate the energy of truth into the life I live, into this present, incarnate existence? How can my life reflect in every action, every thought and feeling, that experience which I know to have been an encounter with truth? At the same time, how do I know that the experience, which to me seemed so very meaningful, was indeed a genuine encounter with truth?
 
Perhaps these questions are most easily answered by suggesting that any experience which broadens rather than narrows, which expands rather than contracts our sensitivity to life and our concern for the welfare of all that lives, must be one that at least approximates truth. When the mind and heart are one and completely open to what is, then truth speaks to us, for we have come into perfect accord with the true nature of things. To come into such perfect accord, there must be a cleansing of the heart and a clearing of the mind, so that we may feel and see and know the One in the midst of the many, forgetting self in the wonder of the Universal Self.
 
There is a beautiful phrase used in one of the Yoga Sutras (section 1, sutra 48) to describe the spiritual state of consciousness known as prajna. It is said of that pure consciousness that it is "truth- and right-bearing," the Sanskrit term being rtambhara. As I. K. Taimni points out in The Science of Yoga, Ultimate Reality "is referred to as Sat [or "isness"] and Its existence in the Universe manifests in two fundamental ways." First, "It constitutes the truth or the very essence of all things." We have this in the motto of the Theosophical Society: Satyam paro nasti dharma, which has been translated, "There is no Religion higher than Truth." The second way in which Ultimate Reality manifests is known as rtam, which Taimni defines as "cosmic order including all laws—natural, moral or spiritual—in their totality which are eternal and inviolable in their nature." So "Rtambhara Prajna is thus that kind of consciousness which gives an unerring perception of the Right and the True underlying manifestation." It is to awaken in ourselves that kind of consciousness that our human journey is undertaken.
 
As we consciously proceed on this human journey, our experiences may well awaken us to new insights if we are open to question the meaning of every experience. When those new insights stir us, transform us, reshape us from within, then it is inevitable that we will act in the world in new ways, ways that reflect the uniqueness of our own encounters with truth. We do not need to ask, "How should I act?" or "What should I do in this or that particular situation?" Our action flows effortlessly from our perception or knowing or direct experience of what is. Let me illustrate.
 
The Theosophical worldview postulates that there is but One Life, that everything in the universe about us in all its diversity is still but an expression of that One Life. HPB told her students, "Existence is one thing, not any collection of things linked together." Annie Besant recognized this unity in the opening words of her well-known invocation: "O Hidden Life, vibrant in every atom." Today many physicists, as well as biologists, ecologists, and leading thinkers in other disciplines, are speaking of the interconnectedness of all living systems. But the idea put forward by HPB is different, because it goes past positing unity as mere interconnection. Rather, as she put it, "fundamentally there is One Being . . . there is nothing outside it." She emphasized this great idea in The Secret Doctrine: "The radical unity of the ultimate essence of each constituent part of compounds in Nature—from star to mineral atom, from the highest Dhyan Chohan to the smallest infusorium, in the fullest acceptation of the term, and whether applied to the spiritual, intellectual or physical worlds—this unity is the fundamental law in Occult Science" (1:120).
 
In her Esoteric Instructions III, HPB reiterated the idea, writing that to understand the occult doctrine "fully and correctly," the student has to know "the great axiomatic truth that the only eternal and living Reality is . . . the one ever-existing Root Essence, immutable and unknowable to our physical senses, but manifest and clearly perceptible to our spiritual natures." And, she added, "once imbued with that basic idea and the further conception that if It is omnipresent, universal and eternal . . . we must have emanated from It, and we must, some day, return to It, and all the rest becomes easy." Not only have we "emanated from It," as she put it, but everything in the manifested universe derives its existence from that One, by whatever name it may be called.
 
It may be easy enough for us to acknowledge the fact that everything in the manifested universe is interconnected, but to actually know that underlying all interconnections is a fundamental Oneness may not be so easy. Yet it is precisely that truth which is to be realized and ultimately acted upon. If, as HPB has stated, this truth is "clearly perceptible to our spiritual natures," then it is for us to awaken that spiritual perception so that we actually experience, in the depths of our own being, the stupendous truth that the source and cause of all manifest existence is one absolute Reality. That, I submit, is indeed the most profound and life-altering experience anyone can have; it is the encounter with "living truth" that opens the doorway to real knowledge. All other truths are secondary, deriving from this one fundamental principle.
 
How does this One Ultimate Reality reflect itself in a world of being and becoming? HPB uses the analogy of the breath, for the aliveness of the One breathing in and breathing out reflects itself in a dynamic polar relationship exhibited everywhere throughout the manifested universe. The basic life action of the universe everywhere repeats the rhythmic order of the One, breathing in and breathing out, a cyclic process in accordance with its own inherent lawfulness. So arises our interconnectedness with all that exists. And recalling the statement quoted earlier that Real Knowledge becomes Fohat or eros, we may say quite simply that the link is love. There is a beautiful passage in Plato's dialogue The Symposium that points to this linkage between the Ultimate Reality, or the world of the gods, as Plato terms it, and the manifested system in which we dwell. Socrates relates what he has learned from Diotima, a wise woman whom he calls his instructress. When Socrates asks Diotima whether love is mortal or immortal, she responds that it is neither, "but in a mean between the two . . . intermediate between the divine and the mortal." Diotima continues by saying that "God mingles not with man, but through Love all the intercourse and converse of gods with men . . . is carried on. The wisdom which understands this is spiritual."
 
Love, then—or, if you prefer, compassion—is the living energy that unites us with the ultimate, by whatever name we may call it—God, Brahma, the One, the Vastness, the realm of the gods. It is the same energy that connects us with everything and everyone in the universe—with the distant stars as with the blade of grass and the pebbles beneath our feet, with those we call our friends as with those we may think of as our enemies. For all is made of the same substance, whether we call it akasha, mulaprakriti, alaya (to use just a few of the terms in The Secret Doctrine) or we designate it as spirit-matter, matter-energy, consciousness-matter.
 
In the world about us, we tend to see only dualities and polarities, and we speak of these as opposites: what is this is not that and what is that is not this. When we change our focus, when we see what is and realize fully that there is only one ultimate substance that manifests itself in a multiplicity of ways, all linked together in that purest of relationships called love—a relationship unen-cumbered by our usual likes and dislikes—then action flows naturally, spontaneously, beautifully. When that great truth is seen in all its magnificent splendor, we know that karma, which is harmony and lawful action, is truly love. We think of karma as the consequences of action, but when we know that inherent in the one ultimate Reality is order, purpose, supreme harmony, then there is only the breathing in, the breathing out, the rhythmic order, which is lawful. That is karma as creativity, as love, the pulsation of the One. Every act becomes one of love, having within it the creative potential to bring into being that which is new, fresh, beautiful, an expression of the true. Consciousness, then, is indeed "truth- and right-bearing." So we walk through the world, not on some path that others tell us about, whether those others be mahatmas or saints or sages or our dearest friends, but on that path that is uniquely our own and which we have become. As The Voice of the Silence so rightly declares: "Thou canst not travel on the Path before thou hast become that Path itself.".
 
Every genuine experience in some measure awakens us to the reality of what is. And if the experience is truly meaningful, then it also vitalizes us and gives us renewed energy and strength. Moreover, it transforms us completely. For experience is not when something happens to us (which is our usual interpretation of the idea of karma). Experience really occurs when we happen to an event in such a way as to change ourselves, alter our perception, gain a new understanding or insight. It is in that change, that new perception or understanding, that the creative nature of karma is realized. For, as we have suggested, karma is that principle which is ever seeking to move us in new directions toward ever greater understanding. Karma is also opportunity, the opportunity to be other than we are now, to be that which we would be, and to do what we would do if we truly wish to be creative agents in building a world at peace. What really matters is not whether we believe in this or that idea, however great the idea, but what we genuinely know. And to know means that we have looked with new eyes upon ageless and immortal principles and translated them into living experience. Theosophy is action; it is transformative action when and if we have fully entered into the truth of Theosophy as a living, vital encounter.
 
Often we speak of a threefold division in the Theosophical life: meditation, study, and service. But for the one whose life is infused with the dynamics of Theosophy, the three are actually one. Every moment is one of total awareness, which is profound meditation, a giving attention to what is. Every moment is a moment of study, of learning, as we "regard earnestly all the life that surrounds you," to use the words of Light on the Path. In each moment there are opportunities for countless little acts of kindness. It is really all so very simple, for living truth is effortless.
 
It is not whether we are a sevenfold or fivefold or threefold being, a heptad of bodies, but whether we know ourselves as a continuum of energy within the one ultimate energy field that we call Reality, and so act as a whole being in tune, in perfect accord with that Oneness.
It is not whether there are processes called reincarnation, one existence following another in endless succession, but whether in this moment we are reborn into a new vision of wholeness from which every action flows outwards to heal as our present presence in the world becomes a benediction on all that exists.
 
It is not whether there is life after death, but rather that in every moment there is a dying and a rebirth, an emerging of the new that can only occur when we let go of the "has been" that we may delight in the "isness" of now, this very moment, with all its rich opportunities to act with lovingkindness, to send out thoughts of love and beauty and strength, to feel at one with all that lives.
 
It is not whether there are mahatmas or masters, the great ones of wisdom and compassion, whether they are still with us, or whether there is some path that leads us to them. Rather the question is the kind of life we are living each day and each moment of each day, how we walk upon the earth, the road we are taking in company with all humanity, all existent beings, and whether we are lending a hand to those who may be stumbling or who may need our help.
 
It is not always whether we are being of service in the world, but perhaps it is a matter of whether we are serving by being present in the world. Action is not always a physical busyness, being busy doing many things. Action may also be silent, for what we are—as Emerson once wrote—speaks louder than any words we say.
 
As for the Theosophical Society, HPB was quite right. So long as there are those in it who in themselves exhibit the "vitality of living truth," it will continue to be a beacon for those who seek in earnestness, a channel of light and beauty and love radiating ever outwards to encompass without boundaries all humanity in the living truth of universal brotherhood.

Joy Mills has studied Theosophy for over sixty years. She has served as president of the American and Australian Sections of the Theosophical Society, international vice-president of the TS, director of the School of Wisdom in Adyar, and director of the Krotona School of Theosophy. A collection of her essays, The One True Adventure: Theosophy and the Quest for Meaning, was published by Quest Books earlier this year.


From the Executive Editor November - December 2008

 Originally printed in the NOVEMBER-DECEMBER 2008 issue of Quest magazine.
Citation: Smoley,  Richard. "From the Executive Editor." Quest  96.6 (NOVEMBER-DECEMBER 2008):203.

Theosophical Society - Richard Smoley is editor of Quest: Journal of the Theosophical Society in America and a frequent lecturer for the Theosophical Society

Practically every magazine has a funny little page at the front, in which the contents of the issue are duly described as a preview for the main attraction and which usually ends with a cheery little fillip such as "We hope you like it!"
 

     I've always had the impression that this feature largely appears in magazines through mere inertia. If you think about it, it's really rather gratuitous. Why should a magazine take a whole page to tell you what its contents are when you readily discover this by simply flipping through the issue? Those who find this too burdensome can resort to the table of contents. And yes, whether they tell you so or not, you can take it as a given that those who put a magazine together hope you enjoy it.

 
     That's why I would like to do something a bit different with this page. Since this is the first time I'm appearing as executive editor of this magazine, an introduction is probably necessary. Some of you may remember me from my previous incarnation as editor of Gnosis, a journal of the Western inner traditions, which was published from 1985 to 1999. I still hear many kind comments about Gnosis, so I'm sure at least some of you remember the magazine. Others may have seen or read some of my books: Hidden Wisdom: A Guide to the Western Inner Traditions (coauthored with Gnosis's founder, Jay Kinney); Inner Christianity: A Guide to the Esoteric Tradition; The Essential Nostradamus; Forbidden Faith: The Secret History of Gnosticism; and most recently, Conscious Love: Insights from Mystical Christianity. On a more strictly Theosophical note, I annotated a new edition of Annie Besant's Esoteric Christianity, which was published by Quest Books in 2006. (Lest you think that this is likely to skew my perspective toward the Western standpoint, let me add that the book that I'm currently writing is largely inspired by the Samkhya, the oldest and most venerable school of Hindu philosophy.) Moreover, I've been acquisitions editor for Quest Books since 2005. At this point, while continuing to do acquisitions for Quest Books, I've stepped in as executive editor of Quest magazine as well. For those of you who want to know more, please visit my personal Web site, www.innerchristianity.com .
 
     As usually happens with a changing of the guard, there will be some modification made to the magazine. Most of these (having to do with design) will appear in the January-February issue, but there is one that we've already decided to institute right now. Because we'd like to have more space for substantive material, particularly book reviews, we are dropping the "Quest Questions" department. (After all, we know that our members are bright enough to think of plenty of questions of their own.) I hope this will also open up space for more letters. As a matter of fact, as I was writing this piece, I received a phone call from a member asking if we take letters to the editor, because he hadn't seen one recently. The short answer is that indeed we do, and we invite them.

 

     To return to the initial topic of what I would like to do with this page: it's quite simple. I think it ought to serve as more of an editorial page that gives my personal perspective on esoteric matters as well as on larger issues in the spiritual culture of our time. Of course, the views here are my personal ones and are not official in any way. Betty Bland still retains her post as editor of the magazine, and her views will continue to appear in her "Viewpoint" column. Since she is president of the Society, her views will be decidedly more official than mine.
     
All this said, there still remains the question of what this magazine ought to be and what kind of stance it ought to take on issues both internal and external. The usual tack taken by many members' journals is a bland middle way, in which strongly stated viewpoints and discussions of controversial matters are discouraged if not omitted entirely. I personally think there ought to be room for wide and disparate viewpoints, particularly in feature articles and in departments such as "Explorations" and "Thinking Allowed."
 
    In any organization with a long tradition and an intricate body of doctrine, it's important to keep reminding ourselves that thinking is allowed. If I were to guess, I would say that the Theosophical Society consists of a small core of members who are dedicated to the memory of HPB, the Masters, and the esoteric doctrine as expounded in their works. In addition to these is a larger body of members who are not nearly so dedicated to Theosophy in this rather specific sense but adhere to the Society's core principles, including the idea that there is a universal "secret doctrine" that has been expressed over the millennia in countless and often apparently contradictory forms, and that the Theosophy formulated by HPB in the late nineteenth century was only one of these. I believe that the Society's journal should be able to accommodate both perspectives (as well as many in between) as well as including literate, stimulating, and spiritually enlivening writing from nonmembers. Whether or not you agree, I hope you will let us know. In any event, as I'm supposed to say on this page, "We hope you like it!"

 

Richard Smoley

Richard Smoley

Executive Editor

 

 
 

Going Around in Circles: The Labyrinths of Theosophy

By Atala Dorothy Toy

Originally printed in the NOVEMBER-DECEMBER 2008 issue of Quest magazine.
Citation: Toy, Atala Dorothy. "Going Around in Circles: The Labyrinths of Theosophy." Quest  96.6 (NOVEMBER-DECEMBER 2008):219-225.


Theosophical Society - Atala Dorothy Toy is president of Crystal Life Technology Inc., a St. Charles, Illinois, company that supplies esoteric, environmental, and dowsing products and information through its store and Web site (www.crystal-life.com ). Atala is secretary of the Board of Trustees of the American Society of Dowsers and cofounder of the Institute for the Study of Interdimensional Cooperation. She is a member of the Labyrinth Society and the Theosophical Society and leads an annual spring equinox walk on the Olcott Labyrinth. Her book, How to Talk with TreesTHE LABYRINTH PATH THAT IS THE PATH is not the path," a Taoist might observe when walking the continually reversing circuits of a labyrinth.

For over 5000 years, the same classical labyrinth pattern has been used for purposes as diverse as creating a town's fortification system, drawing water to arid land, enhancing a meditative focus on one's spiritual life, and balancing the brains of bipolar children. Still, no matter how many times a person walks even the same labyrinth; it is always a new experience.

Labyrinths are ancient energy grids that have waxed and waned in popularity over the centuries. They have appeared on ancient temple walls, pottery, and floors, as the basis for battle plans and fortifications, and as patterns that have been integrated with the landscape to form powerful and energy-rich locations.

In 2001 a group of enthusiasts met in Atlanta, Georgia, and formed the Labyrinth Society. They immediately began a group project of precisely defining the many ambiguous terms historically associated with this figure. The society's definition of a labyrinth (found on its Web site, www.labyrinthsociety.org ) is "a single path or unicursal tool for personal, psychological and spiritual transformation. Labyrinths are thought to enhance right brain activity." Each single round of a labyrinth is called a circuit.

The society's Web site distinguishes labyrinths from mazes in that "a maze can have more than one entrance and numerous choices along the way. The walls are usually high so as to block one from seeing the way out. It is constructed to be a left-brain puzzle." A maze, by its very nature, delights in confusing the path to the truth, forcing an individual to creatively look at and choose from many paths, some of which go nowhere at all!

A labyrinth, by contrast, is a sacred site that gently and inexorably guides one not only to the source, but also back out to the world. Each labyrinth takes on a certain spirit, which comes from the activities that take place on the pattern as well as from the site itself. A labyrinth continually walked by patients at a hospital will develop a different kind of energy from that of one walked by seekers at a quiet spiritual retreat.

During a walk on a labyrinth, which typically takes about twenty minutes to complete, "the mind quiets, the breath slows, and time stretches out. The labyrinth can be used as a path for prayer and meditation," according to the Labyrinth Society's Web site. "It can also be used as a tool of discernment by considering your experiences on the metaphorical level." Depending upon one's orientation and needs, walking a labyrinth can take one on a journey through the astrological realms, the personal transformation of issues, the musical octave, the rainbow of colors, the seven chakras, physiological and mental rebalancing, or silent meditative centering. It can also be a simple joyful romp.

A labyrinth can be left-handed or right-handed. Its orientation is determined by the direction of the first turn after the entrance. Left-handed labyrinths are more intuitive in frequency, while right-handed ones are more outwardly oriented. Jeff Saward, an international labyrinth historian, estimates that approximately two-thirds of the ancient classical labyrinths are right-handed and two-thirds of the modern classical ones are left-handed. The reason for this has not been ascertained, although it is very likely connected to a balancing of energy for that particular time. Thus, ancient people were focused more on stabilizing energy for use on a physical level (such as a city,s fortification), while modern walkers are more often seeking access to spirit. The Theosophical Society's labyrinths are all left-handed. 

Labyrinth Patterns

Theosophical Society - How to Draw a Seven Circle LabyrinthLabyrinths come in different patterns. One of the most ancient and most common, the classical labyrinth, has been found on walls, pottery, and coins going back thousands of years. It is associated with nature traditions, and its basic construction is based on a seed pattern that grows out in an organic manner (figure 1).

The entry door for the classical labyrinth can originate from any direction and is often determined by the energies of the site. Placement of the classical labyrinth is usually done by dowsing and asking the land itself various questions, including: Is it appropriate for the labyrinth to be located here? Is a certain design appropriate? Where should the center be? What size should it be? What direction should it face? Are there other features that should be included? For many classical labyrinth builders, the power of this form comes from the earth and from the mechanics of its interface with the earth energies of that location.

Included in this category is the meander, based on the Greek key pattern. While this square pattern appears to "meander" along a linear path, its basic form has been shown to evolve into that of the round classical labyrinth. The Roman labyrinth is a classical variation: square, round, or polygonal in shape and often used on floors, perhaps originating as a means of energy stabilization and protection for that area. There is also a three-dimensional classical labyrinth, which occurs when the pattern is adjusted around the specific topography of a site. One of the most famous of these sites is Glastonbury Tor in England, a very high-energy sacred site that has a seven-circuit labyrinth cascading down its sides. Builders will sometimes construct a topographical labyrinth around a tree or boulder or to fit a specific site configuration. It is an excellent way to rebalance energy on any piece of property.

The pattern of the classical labyrinth looks like the brain, and walking it is a dance with the forces of the universe. Just as in life, the goal is to reach the central source, but the path to it takes one close and far away by turns, until finally, the center is attained. At this point, the seeker realizes that his journey is only half done, for now he must dance the energy of the source back out to the world.

Another name for the classical labyrinth is the Cretan labyrinth, from its association with Crete and the Minotaur. In this Greek myth, the Minotaur, a monster that was half-bull and half-man, lived in the middle of a maze—shown on ancient Cretan coins to be a classical labyrinth in design. Young Athenian men and women were sacrificed to the Minotaur until the hero Theseus, assisted by Ariadne, daughter of King Minos of Crete, finally killed the bull. The Cretans, who were at that time (the middle of the second millennium BC) a powerful nation, used labyrinthine forms throughout their art, architecture, and fortifications.

The classical labyrinth's effectiveness in controlling and protecting goes back thousands of years. It has been depicted in ancient texts describing the fabled military wheel offensive of the Kauravas in the battle of Kurukshetra as described in the Mahabharata. Interestingly, these diagrams show a right-handed entrance. Other ancient texts depict the famous Trojan wall defenses in the form of a classical labyrinth. This defensive pattern was exported to towns throughout the Mediterranean and up into the British Isles. A town using this pattern was often called "Troy Town" in the local language.

In modern times, the classical labyrinth is sometimes overlaid with a medicine wheel, so that the individual is not only walking into the circle but is also aware of the cyclical changes that occur as he or she traverses each circuit.

The Tohono O'odham Indians of Arizona have as a part of their spiritual tradition a pattern called the "Man in the Maze." A classical-style labyrinth, this image signifies the journey each person must take through the twists and turns, difficulties and opportunities of life.

Runic labyrinths have come into use over the past twenty years. In this system, each circuit is dowsed for the rune energy manifested at specific spots and a glyph is embedded at that location. As someone walks the labyrinth, he or she pauses at each location, merges with that particular rune energy, and then moves on.

Theosophical Society - The Medieval Chartres Labyrinth DesignThe medieval labyrinth evolved during the early Middle Ages as a church design and is set up using sacred geometry; it is usually charted and then applied to a site. It is sometimes called the Chartres labyrinth, because the design appears on the floor of this French cathedral. The medieval labyrinth is totally round and divides into four equal-sized quadrants that together form a cross. Its power comes from the act of walking it as a metaphysical journey of contemplation on Christ consciousness. The medieval labyrinth is usually entered on the west, so that the individual starts by facing east, the site of the rising sun (the risen Son). A medieval labyrinth has a more specific focus on theology: it is considered by its advocates to be a form of body prayer or walking prayer that is leading the walker to God (figure 2).

There are also free-form labyrinths, created by individuals using unique plans and united only in their definition as "unicursal labyrinthine pathways or multiple paths designed not to confuse, but to enhance spiritual perception or peaceful energies." These are often labyrinths designed to fit into an unusual piece of property or to function as art pieces. 

Walking the Path 

Why walk a labyrinth? As with all great forms of wisdom, the answer is simple. The reasons why may fill volumes. Labyrinths have generated hundreds of tomes explaining this pattern's endlessly intriguing nature and inherent value.

Traveling the seven-circuit classical labyrinth as a journey through the chakras is extremely powerful (figure 3). In the diagram shown here, you can see that the seven circuits are numbered from the outside in sequence. This correlates to the seven chakras:  

1. Base chakra. Your relationship to the universe
2. Sacral chakra. Your relationship to the community in which you exist
3. Solar plexus. Your perception of yourself
4. Heart. The point of oneness in the human body with the all; the balance between the lower and higher chakras
5. Throat. How you speak your truth
6. Third Eye. How you see the truth
7. Crown. Your spiritual relation to the universe 

In addition, there are two other levels: 

8. The Source itself
9. The outside world in which the labyrinth, or individual, resides 

Theosophical Society - Classical Labyrinths with Paths numbered When you walk the labyrinth, you are actually walking the circuits in the following sequence: 32147658. This is as you go in. When you exit, you do so in reverse: 85674123 and then you emerge via the "birth canal" into the outside world.

The walk through the seven circuits is seen as the journey to self-realization. You enter through the solar plexus (3), asking the question "Who am I?", and then proceed to define yourself according to your community (2) and the world (1) before realizing that the answer is actually inside yourself and you focus on the heart (4). The heart tells you that the answer is in spirit, and so you attempt to travel to source, getting as far as the crown chakra (7). But here you realize that the answer is more complex than it seemed at first and you travel next into the third eye for wisdom (6), and into the throat chakra to find a way to express what you have experienced (5). Only then are you fully prepared to enter the one source of all (8).

Now that you are centered in the source and gazing out, you realize you are only halfway through your journey. Once you have acquired this knowledge of source, you are obliged to return by way of the same paths of energy to bring this message to the world (9).

An astrological understanding of the labyrinths is favored by John Algeo, international vice-president of the Theosophical Society (see Explorations in the January-February 2001 Quest). Algeo describes the significance of each circuit in this manner, along with the planets and the days of the week traditionally associated with them: 

3. Mars. Desire, Tuesday
2. Jupiter. Self-identity, Thursday
1. Saturn. Empirical mind, Saturday
4. Sun. Vitality, Sunday
7. Moon. Form, Monday
6. Mercury. Intuition, Wednesday
5. Venus. Pure mind, Friday 

Algeo has also related the seven circuits to the seven principles in Theosophy. As quoted in an article in The American Theosophist describing Algeo's 1995 workshop at Stil-Light in 1995, this pairing relates, for instance, "Mars to passion (kama), Venus to intuition (buddhi-manas), the Moon to the etheric (linga-sharira) and Saturn to lower mind (kama-manas)." (See Lewis Lucas, "The Labyrinth at Stil-Light," The American Theosophist, early winter 1995, p. 11.)

Prayers for Problem Solving 

In his book Labyrinths, Sig Lonegren provides many ways to build and work with this land energy form. He offers an explanation of how to walk a labyrinth to solve personal problems. It is similar to walking the chakras, in this case focusing on a specific issue you wish to have clarified as you traverse the world of energy.

Some free spirits who are loath to be penned in by any explanation prefer just to walk the labyrinth and experience it. Robert Ferre, a well-known labyrinth builder, refers to this as "taking a stroll with your soul." He observes that the movement of energy through a human and through nature is circular in form, just like a labyrinth. He recommends that people simply ask a question and walk. Just walk: be patient, quiet, attentive, open, and not insistent. You cannot force an answer; it needs to simply descend into your awareness.

Children often consider the labyrinth to be a game and run one for the simple joy of running. Adults often find it extremely liberating to run it themselves.

You can also dance the labyrinth with a partner. Dancing the labyrinth is an ancient ritual. Sometimes called the Crane Dance, it was performed in pagan circles as an entrance to spring or to symbolize the reemergence of life after the death of winter. This dance was at one time extremely popular, as can be deduced by the numerous edicts of the medieval church forbidding the performance of the dance on church labyrinths.

About a decade ago, labyrinth enthusiast John Appleton observed that two people could traverse much of a labyrinth while holding hands. Nowadays, at labyrinth gatherings, the Appleton Dance is sometimes performed as an enjoyable social experience and sometimes as a profound experience of the partnership of all life forms in the universe.

During much of the middle part of the labyrinth journey, two people can walk together. But at the start and the end, each person must go alone. To perform this dance: 

Theosophical Society - Position Points of Partners Joining Hands Within a LabyrinthThe partners (or a group of people) determine an issue or energy they wish to work on together. While one stands at the entrance of the labyrinth, another carries the issue to spirit, depositing it in the source and asking spirit for the appropriate consciousness to bring back out. As this person returns, he travels down to express the new consciousness through the crown chakra (7), third eye (6), and throat (5) before coming to the heart (4), demonstrating that communication requires working with others. At this point he joins hands with his partner, who is waiting at the start of her own path to self-awareness (3). The two share energy until they finally separate, the second person moving into the source on her own and the other exiting the labyrinth to offer the message to the entire outer world. On exiting, the second person can complete the walk on her own, or share in a similar way with the next person in line (figure 4). 

Physiology and Earth Balancing 

A good deal of work is being done today in under-standing the physiological benefits of labyrinth walking. This has occurred as a result of the observations of facilitators who find that adults and children with learning disabilities often emerge from the labyrinth with at least a temporary improvement in their cognitive abilities. This observation has engendered a number of medically oriented studies. It is currently understood that the many left-to-right and right-to-left turns experienced while walking the labyrinth causes a vestibular response that temporarily balances the logical and artistic activities of the brain. In lay terms, it causes brain fluid to move back and forth across the middle line of the brain, helping to balance and integrate the different capacities of the right and left sides of the brain. This integration remains for a time after the individual emerges from the labyrinth. Sometimes, when the labyrinth is walked continuously, these benefits become more permanent. For this reason, as well as for the peace that is engendered, a number of hospitals around the country have installed labyrinths on their grounds.

Walking is an essential part of this healing process, since the body is a processing plant and synthesizes and grounds what the head can only conjecture. When someone cannot walk the labyrinth on her own, placing her on a horse and having the horse traverse the labyrinth can also have profoundly beneficial results. In this case, one is combining the known therapeutic energy of the horse with that of the labyrinth. Some therapists are working with horses and labyrinths to assist learning-disabled children and children with bipolar issues, dyslexia, attention deficit disorder (ADD), and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). In this case, a specially constructed labyrinth is used, with circuit paths from three feet to eight feet in width so that a horse can navigate it. A therapist often walks beside the patient.

Dowsers, those formidable individuals who use rods and pendulums to detect and affect energy, often incorporate labyrinths into their work to change, alleviate, enhance, and hold beneficial energies for a piece of land or for Earth herself. Water domes and flows are often charted as emerging from labyrinths, and this engenders the classic question: which came first? The labyrinth form has a way of calling up and holding energy in an area, and one often finds cows, sheep, and other animals grazing or resting on a labyrinth. The classical labyrinth has been found among the giant Nazca Lines in Peru. These mysterious diagrams have been conjectured to fill many purposes, among them serving as a means to draw water to that high, inaccessible, arid region. 

Theosophical Labyrinths 

Four Theosophical centers in America offer classical-style labyrinths. The labyrinths serve their local communities and also help connect the retreat centers to the unified field of consciousness that the Theosophical Society embodies.

Beginning in 1995, John Algeo, at that time president of the Theosophical Society in America, began offering lectures on the value of the labyrinth for the spiritual life including a talk at the 1998 Inter-American Theosophical Federation Meeting, "The Labyrinth of Life," and in 2001, he wrote "The Labyrinth: A Brief Introduction to its History, Meaning and Use" for Quest magazine. That summer, Algeo and Diana March participated in a retreat at Stil-Light Theosophical Center in North Carolina, where they led a workshop in which participants laid out and constructed a stone labyrinth. (Unfortunately, Stil-Light is no longer operative as a Theosophical center.) Since then, Algeo and March have each hosted lectures and workshops on the value of the labyrinth at regional and national gatherings.

All of the Theosophical labyrinths are of the seven-circuit classical style and are in continual use by many people in their areas. But here the similarities end, for each labyrinth is made of different materials and has been integrated into its area's landscape in its own unique manner. Each is a cooperative work in progress, a joint partnership among the land, the spirits of the land, the energies of the TS, and the people who walk at that location.

Theosophical Society - The Olcott Labyrinth at the Wheaton National CenterThe best known of the Theosophical labyrinths is the Olcott Labyrinth at the Society's American headquarters in Wheaton, Illinois . The Olcott labyrinth is highly regarded by enthusiasts and is listed in the worldwide labyrinth locator maintained by the Labyrinth Society. Fifty feet in diameter, it is constructed of circular paving stones set in a field of sand-washed pebbles and is set in an open grass lawn to the west of the L. W. Rogers Building. Its mouth is to the north. The building of the labyrinth was implemented by John Algeo during his term as national president. Neil Harris assisted in siting the labyrinth and Dan Doolin was responsible for directing the grounds department in excavating and building the foundation. Overseen by Diana March, the Young Theosophists, organized by Joan McDougall, donated the labor for the laying of the labyrinth pattern in concrete pavers with surrounding stone pebbles.

In recent years, the TS has hosted an annual spring equinox labyrinth walk at the Olcott Labyrinth for its members and the public. Other regional retreat centers hold occasional formal events around their labyrinths, and all the labyrinths are generally open to the public during daylight hours (figure 5).

The other TS labyrinths may be found at:

Pumpkin Hollow Retreat Center, Craryville. New York. Located in the heart of the Adirondacks, this labyrinth is thirty-three feet in diameter with an eastern entrance. It was constructed during a labyrinth workshop in June 1996 from the quartz stones that abound in that area. When its builders were planning the labyrinth, they queried the earth energies, who chose, not the nearby site its human designers wanted, but one located a good twelve-minute walk away on a quiet, wooded rise at the far end of the property. Visitors often carry quartz stones and add them to help build up the labyrinth lines. Wildflowers grow among the stones, further outlining the circuits (figure 6).

Krotona School of Theosophy, Ojai, California. Diana March provided plans for the Krotona Labyrinth, which was constructed in 1997 as part of a workshop led by John Algeo. This labyrinth is thirty-nine feet in diameter. It has an entrance on the west and is located in an open meadow next to the Krotona School, with a view of the surrounding mountains. Originally laid out with powdered chalk, it has gradually been filled in with stones placed by walkers.

Camp Indralaya, Orcas Island, Washington state. Diana March traveled to Washington state in April 1999 to lead a labyrinth work-shop at Camp Indralaya. This labyrinth, twenty-eight feet in diameter, was built with materials local to that site: stones, shells, and driftwood (figure 8). It is located on a lawn just behind and below (north of) the main dining hall. The lawn is on a bluff above Judd Cove, which is part of a larger body of water called East Sound.


References 

Conty, Patrick. The Genesis and Geometry of the Labyrinth. Rochester, Vt.: Inner Traditions, 2002.

Ferre, Robert. Constructing Classical Labyrinths. St. Louis, Mo.: Labyrinth Enterprises, 2002.
”. Church Labyrinths. St. Louis, Mo.: One Way Press, 2001.
Lonegren, Sig. Labyrinths. New York: Sterling, 2001.
 

Atala Dorothy Toy is president of Crystal Life Technology Inc., a St. Charles, Illinois, company that supplies esoteric, environmental, and dowsing products and information through its store and Web site (www.crystal-life.com ). Atala is secretary of the Board of Trustees of the American Society of Dowsers and cofounder of the Institute for the Study of Interdimensional Cooperation. She is a member of the Labyrinth Society and the Theosophical Society and leads an annual spring equinox walk on the Olcott Labyrinth. Her book, How to Talk with Trees (Red Wheel/Weiser/Conari), is due in bookstores next summer.


Subcategories